Santa Cruz Indymedia :
Santa Cruz Indymedia

Commentary :: Civil & Human Rights

BTL:Palestinians Suffering in Lebanese Refugee Camps Hold Onto Hope for...

...'Right of Return'~Interview with Raida Hatoum, Lebanese activist and organizer, conducted by Between the Lines' Stefan Christoff
Palestinians Suffering in Lebanese Refugee Camps Hold Onto Hope for "Right of Return"

Interview with Raida Hatoum, Lebanese activist and organizer, conducted by Stefan Christoff

The United Nations estimates that there are over 400,000 Palestinian refugees living in impoverished camps scattered throughout Lebanon. Refugees there represent the living face of the displacement crisis for Palestinians worldwide, while also providing context for the Palestinian struggle for the right of return.

The issue of the right of return has been the focus of recent international headlines with the "disengagement plan" put forward by Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, endorsed by U.S. President George W. Bush and vocally supported by Democratic presidential candidate John Kerry. The "disengagement plan" foresees the eventual evacuation of major Jewish settlements in the Gaza Strip but rejects the internationally recognized right of return for millions of Palestinian refugees displaced during the creation of the state of Israel in 1948. For Palestinian refugees in Lebanon, whose political and social identity is defined by a belief in the right of return, the "disengagement plan" put forward by Sharon is a devastating blow.

Palestinian refugees living in Lebanon today say they are subjected to systematic repression by the Lebanese government. They are forbidden from owning property, traveling freely -- working in over 70 professions and unable to obtain proper health care. During a recent trip to Beirut, Between The Lines' Stefan Christoff spoke with Raida Hatoum, a Lebanese activist who works with Najdeh, a women's NGO network operating in Palestinian refugee camps throughout Lebanon.

For more information, visit the Beirut Indymedia website at

Related links:

To get more information about the global movement for the Palestinian Right of Return, visit:

The Electronic Intifada, at Publishes news, commentary, analysis, and reference materials about the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict from a Palestinian perspective Tikkun Magazine, A community of people from many faiths and traditions, with a vision of healing and transforming our world. Guided by the principle of to achieve social justice, ecological sanity, and world peace, and the inner healing needed to foster loving relationships, as well as a generous attitude toward the world and toward others

LISTEN to this week's half-hour program of Between The Lines by clicking on one of the links below:
"Between The Lines" is a half-hour syndicated radio news magazine that each week features a summary of under-reported news stories and interviews with activists and journalists who offer progressive perspectives on international, national and regional political, economic and social issues. Because "Between The Lines" is independent of all publications, media networks or political parties, we are able to bring a diversity of voices to the airwaves generally ignored or marginalized by the major media. For more information on this week's topics and to check out our text archive listing topics and guests presented in previous programs visit:
"Between the Lines," WPKN 89.5 FM's weekly radio news magazine can be heard Tuesdays at 5:30 p.m. ET; Wednesdays at 8 a.m. ET and Saturdays at 2 p.m. ET (Wednesday's show airs at 7:30 a.m. ET during fundraising months of April and October).
For an email subscription of "Between The Lines Weekly Summary" which features a RealAudio link to the week's program for Between The Lines, send an email to btlsummary-subscribe (at)
For an email subscription of "Between The Lines Q&A" which features a RealAudio link and weekly transcript to one of the interviews featured on Between The Lines, send an email to btlqa-subscribe (at)
betweenthelines (at)
Distributed by Squeaky Wheel Productions, Inc.
(c)2004 Squeaky Wheel Productions, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

New Comments are disabled, please visit


Lebanese treat fellow Arabs like Dogs

the reality is that the Arabs are the ones that are responsible for treating their fellows like Dogs.

Israel also had to contend with refugees when their fellow Jews were forced out of all the ARAB countries that they had lived in for centuries. Israel accepted them with open arms and integrated these Jewish refugess into the Israeli culture and society.

In the middle east its the ARABS that have treated their fellows with contempt and racism.

There is no more a right to return

First, the author does not mention opinion polls taken in the Palestinian camps outside of Israel in which only 10% indicate any interest in "returning" and that number drops to 5% if it means living under Israeli authority.

2nd, anyone who was really displaced in 1948 is a minimum of 56 years old now.

3rd, the Palestinian population on the West Bank has tripled since 1967. Obviously, a lot of "returning" has already happened--mostly due to illegal immigration and partially to the extremely high birth rate of the Palestinians today.

4th: Israel has already returned 170,000 Arabs into Israel through their normal immigration services. Palestinian Arabs displaced by the war in 1948, have simply filled out forms for re-entry, submitted proof of residency such as rent receipts, deeds, birth certificates, etc., and once approved were re-admitted into Israel as Israeli citizens. From what I understand, this process ended with the Oslo Accords in 1993.

That said, I do think we need to find a solution for the people living in the camps. They obviously deserve to have a decent place to live and the rights of citizenship somewhere. But I think Israel has already done more to help out the Palestinian Arab refugees whose plight began with the Arabs' decision to attack the brand new nation of Israel.


No events for this day.

view calendar week
add an event


Media Centers

Syndication feeds

Account Login

This site made manifest by dadaIMC software