"There is no evidence, to my knowledge, that the Passover suicide attacks were conducted by someone from the Jenin refugee camp. That aside, the action of attacking and demolishing a huge area of the camp and killing at least 55 people, half of them civilian, is collective punishment."

The suicide murderer was from Tulkarem. The area of the "camp" in Jenin wasn't all that large. The Israelis were met by heavy resistence...what was that a few old ladie in burqas screaming? You do remember the ten year old boy that blew himself up (more likely the brave warriors of Islam detonated the explosive from behind cover) killing 13 brave soldiers who risked their lives trying to minimize civilian casualties...Killing armed combatants is NOT collective punishment...it's war...