1. Lee claims:
"Theya [Israeli refuseniks] are the equivalents of the Jews who worked in the death camps to round up other Jews for the Nazis."
This is a preposterous comparison, Lee. It's outrageous for two reasons: (a) those people never stooped to the moral abyss of those Jewish Kapos who willingly cooperated with the Nazis, and (b) most Jewish collaborators with the Nazis performed their roles reluctantly.
2. Argue distorts and lies:
"So the Zionist here is claiming that the origins of Palestinian nationalism are in Nazism. This is absurd. Of course the real roots of Palestinian nationalism are in the Zionist Israeli settler state occupying and eliminating the Palestinian homeland through terror and racist discrimination."
Again he's at his slick stunt.
I didn't claim earlier that Palestinism is entirely rooted in Nazism. I said Palestinism has certain Nazi roots in Hajj Amin al-Husseini's zealous collaboration with, and support and encouragement of, the Nazi movement and its extermination machine. Anyone can scroll up and see how the slick-trick Argue has distorted what I said.
I believe that aside from pointing out there's never been a Palestinian homeland, Argue's other nonsense has been amply refuted.
Two comments
Date Edited: 13 Jan 2005 10:40:00 PM
"Theya [Israeli refuseniks] are the equivalents of the Jews who worked in the death camps to round up other Jews for the Nazis."
This is a preposterous comparison, Lee. It's outrageous for two reasons: (a) those people never stooped to the moral abyss of those Jewish Kapos who willingly cooperated with the Nazis, and (b) most Jewish collaborators with the Nazis performed their roles reluctantly.
2. Argue distorts and lies:
"So the Zionist here is claiming that the origins of Palestinian nationalism are in Nazism. This is absurd. Of course the real roots of Palestinian nationalism are in the Zionist Israeli settler state occupying and eliminating the Palestinian homeland through terror and racist discrimination."
Again he's at his slick stunt.
I didn't claim earlier that Palestinism is entirely rooted in Nazism. I said Palestinism has certain Nazi roots in Hajj Amin al-Husseini's zealous collaboration with, and support and encouragement of, the Nazi movement and its extermination machine. Anyone can scroll up and see how the slick-trick Argue has distorted what I said.
I believe that aside from pointing out there's never been a Palestinian homeland, Argue's other nonsense has been amply refuted.
New Comments are disabled, please visit Indybay.org/SantaCruz